| Past Awards | ||||
| Season | Offensive Player of the Year | Defensive Player of the Year | Most Valuable Player | Most Improved |
| 2013 | Omar Khamissa | Kumail Meghani | Hasan Raza | N/A |
| 2014 | Khizer Jamal | Kumail Meghani | Mustafa Kamani | N/A |
| 2015 (I) | Mustafa Kamani | Ahmed Goralwalla | Ali Haroon | N/A |
| 2015 (O) | Ali Jessa | Ali Haroon | Khizer Jamal | N/A |
| 2016 (I) | Nihal Jamal | Ali Haroon | Ammar Jessa | N/A |
| 2016 (O) | Shaneali Kara | Farhan Ratansi | Khizer Jamal | N/A |
| 2017 (I) | Omar Khamissa | Mujtaba Abidi | Kumail Meghani | Murtaza Shah |
| Champions | |||
| Season | Playoff Champion | Captain | Regular Season Champion |
| 2013 | Patriots | Kumail Meghani | Lions |
| 2014 | Packers | Muhammad Ali | Texans |
| 2015 (I) | Packers | Muhammad Ali | Packers |
| 2015 (O) | Patriots | Kumail Meghani | Vikings |
| 2016 (I) | Chargers | Mustafa Kamani | Patriots |
| 2016 (O) | Patriots | Kumail Meghani | Vikings |
| 2017 (I) | Colts | Imran Ebrahim | Colts |
*Note: The 2017 Colts are the ONLY undefeated team in the history of the MFL, with a final record of 10-0-1.